Brown Banana plant?
 

Ever heard of a Brown Banana? Old man I ran into said he has been growing banana plants for 30 years. Said every year he gets banana's. He did say he brings some of them in his garage to keep the p-stems. He called them Brown Banana plants,said it has been giving him fruit for years. He emailed me pictures and I can't tell what it is. As far as the type. I'm not good at posting pics on here. He said he would send me full pics of them. They usually get 12-15ft tall I think he said. Also said he has yellow banana plants not sure he said it got fruit. Only one I know is the chinese yellow which gets a flower thats it. The leaves have no markings on them and are are kinds rough and curl up on the sides.

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

We definitely need to see photos to help at all. If you want to, PM me, and we can arrange to post the photos here.

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

pm sent

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

Just looking at the location I would say oroinco but thats a guess...

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

Nope its not a orc as I have one and doesn't look like mine. But pictures are hard to tell of course.

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

You know there is tall & dwarf

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

Yes I know. Maybe once I see pics of the whole plants 12ft tall then we can tell. A guy at a well know nursery claims this big bunch of banana plants he has. Our cavendish,which they are only 6ft tall but don't have any markings on them at all. I had four foot plants that still had alittle purple on the leaves. He has had them in there landscape for years and just cuts them down. They always come back. His area gets hit with alot of frost and cold snaps because of it being a low lying area. He is like 45mins away. Even me living a few miles from the ocean and a huge river don't think they would survive for me. So I think his were maybe crossed with something else to make them extra hardy?

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

Sounds interesting. Keep us posted.

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

Sent Gabe the pics. Hope they aren't Orconios as this would have been a waste. But like I said they don't look like mine at all. But soil,age,shade/full sun,morph can make plants look different enough. I'm a cactus guy also and I have about 50 cacti and same are from the same plant but they still look different. Mother plant is older and has less spines and cut pad that grew into a plant has longer or more spines through out. :lurk:

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

Here are the photos.








They are definitely not an 'Orinoco' of any type. I would say they are a Cavendish, but hard to say which cultivar without seeing the fully mature bunch. Also, they appear to be a bit stunted from less than optimal conditions, so in a warmer climate they would look rather different.

Cool Thanks.I'm still waiting on more photo's and info.

Any thoughts on what nanner could be called Yellows and give fruit. Thats another he has?

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

Common names are not very good to ID plants by, and in particular since these common names are very unusual and non-descriptive, they are really no help. Since edible bananas do not have specific scientific names either, it can very difficult to guess anything based off the name unless you know very well what plants are in a specific area and what the local names are for those plants, even then though there is a lot of fuzzyness in IDing them.

The best thing to do in your case is to post photos since these common names are not going to lead anywhere.

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

Those pic's certainly look funny; well out of the ordinary, Ok lethargic... @ least they have nanner's :^)

Re: Brown Banana plant?
 

One picture makes them look like plastic leaves. I know this old man isn't making this up. He is really nice and down to earth and emailed me other pictures of bushes or flowers he grows. I met him through my Master Gardeners Class in school. My teacher brought up to the class I grew banana plants and stored them in the winter. After class this guy came up to me and we talked about his nanners.